Reviews

Kun kaupunki suljettiin – Wuhanin kohtalonhetket by Fang Fang

robloz55's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is 2 months worth of diary entries written by a professional author living in the city of WUHAN in Hubei Province, in China. Wuhan is the centre of where the Covid-19 virus began. It was first reported in December 2019, hence the designation of 19 in the name. But between 31 December and 20 January, visitors and tourists continued to visit the city and then began spreading the virus as they travelled home.

Wuhan is a city of 9 million people, It was not put into lockdown until 22 January 2020. This diary was started on 25 January and runs to 24 March 2020.

The authors name is Fang Fang. She is a professional writer. She was aged 65 at the time of writing this diary, and has written some 100 books, mostly novels. In this diary she asks questions of the hospitals, the city administration and even of the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) as the numbers of cases and deaths began rising. She has diabetes and she lives alone. Her ex-husband lives elsewhere in the city, as does her daughter. She also says that she herself is not a member of the communist party.

Some of these diary entries are repetitive, and a little boring. There also seems to be rather a lot of "name dropping" as well. Fang Fang seems to know lots of people from the upper echelons of the city administration.

There is NOT one mention of the Cruise ship Diamond Princess which was tied up in Japan with the virus rampaging amongst the crew and passengers in January and February 2020. There is also not one mention of the announcement by the W.H.O officially calling this virus a Global Pandemic.

Some of these diary entries were removed from the online forum where Fang Fang posted them. The censorships seems to go both ways. Some news items cannot get out, and most international news does not get in.

In Late January 2020 my family transportation broke down and we were no longer able to go out to buy food and groceries. We had to start ordering our groceries online and have them delivered. It took 6 weeks for the transportation to be repaired. By the time it was repaired, it was clear that this virus was spreading very fast, so my family chose to just continue to stay at home.

I have now been housebound for 2 years and 2 months. I have been outside only twice. Once to see the doctor just 2 days before the Pandemic was officially announced by the W.H.O in March 2020, The second time was in the summer of 2021 to get my second vaccine jab. I have not been outside since then.

I give this 3 stars. It is interesting, but somewhat dry. Especially if (like me) you have no cultural interest in or connection with China.

FYI - There is also news that today - 28 March 2022 - the city of Shanghai (26 million) is now being forced back into another lockdown as covid case numbers begin to rise again.

tablife's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

It's been 5 years since COVID started, so it was a fitting time to revisit the beginning of the pandemic as documented in Fang Fang's diary who bravely posted about what was going on inside of Wuhan, even calling on the government to take greater responsibility (virtually unheard of in China). Not having the familiarity of the Chinese people she was referencing made parts of the book uninteresting, but I wish I'd read this when it came out in 2020.

emilyacgm's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

An averaged rating-- 4 stars for timeliness and interesting view of life within Wuhan's quarantine; 2 stars for tedium, tangentsm and just wanting it to end already, a little like the pandemic.

jackfletch's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Excellent chronicle that manifested itself in so many ways here in the US months later. Would have been good to have had all this information earlier. This woman is a force of nature. Will look into getting translations of her other works.

katep27's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.5/5stars

This was VERY informative and interesting but, just like actual quarantine lol, was a bit repetitive. I'm sure this would have been more fun if you were keeping up as she was posting each day and I see that little ray of hope these entries probably gave people, but reading it all at once was a bit much. Other than that, this is such a perfect little time capsule of 2020 and will be probably studied for years to come.

faliiza's review

Go to review page

emotional informative reflective fast-paced

3.5

corymogk's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Decent though long - favorite part is the translator’s notes. Is there a potential book on the trolling?

biene98's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative reflective slow-paced

3.0

jujubahn's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative reflective medium-paced

3.0

clairealex's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Journal entries are a good primary source but they are not interesting reading.