Scan barcode
scrooge3's review against another edition
4.0
Novella originally published in [b:Novelty: Four Stories|209493|Novelty Four Stories|John Crowley|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1348005193l/209493._SY75_.jpg|43235827], May 1989. 1990 World Fantasy Award winner and 1990 Nebula Award finalist.
This is a complex and intricate time travel story, certainly one of the best of its type, that looks at the inevitability of events and the hubris of those who have the power to try and change those events. There are several plot threads that slowly converge near the end, and certain characters playing more than one role. This is the kind of story that would reveal new insights upon rereading. John Crowley is probably best known for his novel [b:Little, Big|90619|Little, Big|John Crowley|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1435452849l/90619._SY75_.jpg|518635] (1981), but he certainly shows with this novella that he is a master wordsmith at any length.
I read this story in the anthology [b:Novelties and Souvenirs: Collected Short Fiction|90623|Novelties and Souvenirs Collected Short Fiction|John Crowley|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1287949102l/90623._SY75_.jpg|87461] (2004). 102 pages
This is a complex and intricate time travel story, certainly one of the best of its type, that looks at the inevitability of events and the hubris of those who have the power to try and change those events. There are several plot threads that slowly converge near the end, and certain characters playing more than one role. This is the kind of story that would reveal new insights upon rereading. John Crowley is probably best known for his novel [b:Little, Big|90619|Little, Big|John Crowley|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1435452849l/90619._SY75_.jpg|518635] (1981), but he certainly shows with this novella that he is a master wordsmith at any length.
I read this story in the anthology [b:Novelties and Souvenirs: Collected Short Fiction|90623|Novelties and Souvenirs Collected Short Fiction|John Crowley|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1287949102l/90623._SY75_.jpg|87461] (2004). 102 pages
larsdradrach's review against another edition
3.0
A small gem of a time travel story focused on the British Empire keeping its world domination and maintaining its African colonies.
It’s cleverly constructed and beautifully written with a at times complex language, which challenges a reader like me who not native English spoken.
It’s probably a book I will return to and enjoy even more the second time around.
It’s cleverly constructed and beautifully written with a at times complex language, which challenges a reader like me who not native English spoken.
It’s probably a book I will return to and enjoy even more the second time around.
deimosremus's review
adventurous
informative
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
yevolem's review against another edition
4.0
Caspar Last has invented a time machine, though he only calls it that out of convenience because it isn't a machine and he doesn't believe that time exists. While there's much he could do with it, he's only interested in using it once to enrich himself. To him, it's all in the research and proof that it works. After that, who cares? It's all proven and doesn't matter any longer and it's onto the next project. As you'd expect, someone else feels differently and acquires the ability to time travel from him. Denys Winterset is approached by a man who offers him to join a time traveling organization that changes the past to their preferences. Originally it was founded by Cecil Rhodes, leader of Rhodesia, for the purpose of furthering the British Empire, but their aims have now changed. They believe Winterset to be integral to their existence, and he is, far more than any of them could ever know.
Crowley is a joy to simply read, even when the actual content isn't all that suited to my tastes, though in this case it was. Time travel is one of my preferred themes and I like to see what sort the author employs. In this case time traveling is orthogonal, meaning the traveler can never return to the exact same timeline they were in and they always travel to one that is slightly different. Due to its peculiarities this results in quite the consequences. The closest other to it that I can think of is the film, Primer, though elements of it can be seen in various other time travel media, ranging from All You Zombies to El ministerio del tiempo. A detailed explanation is given for technical aspects of how the time travel would hypothetically work, though the specific process isn't ever explicitly shown. As happens with time travel stories, the narrative isn't told linearly, and there's some initial obfuscation of identities, though eventually everything is clearly explained to the reader.
In terms of its historical accuracy, it reads very well and is clearly researched, which is evidenced by the bibliography provided at the end. Sometimes (oftentimes?) with science fiction the origin of the book simply seems to be that the author has been deeply researching some area of interest and then decide they want to write about it. I've seen this in a wide variety of works and overall I think doing so enhances their writing with the distinct flavor of their research. That goes from "write what you know" to "write what you learned."
Once again I'd like to thank yitr for suggesting that I read Crowley sooner than later. It's only a matter of time before I'll have read almost all, if not all, of Crowley's fiction. All of his works that I've read so far have had the sort of imaginative novelty that I particularly appreciate. Each one has that special something where even if I didn't enjoy it I can still respect it for what it is. Even his most read work is only mildly known, so I recommend you read him.
Crowley is a joy to simply read, even when the actual content isn't all that suited to my tastes, though in this case it was. Time travel is one of my preferred themes and I like to see what sort the author employs. In this case time traveling is orthogonal, meaning the traveler can never return to the exact same timeline they were in and they always travel to one that is slightly different. Due to its peculiarities this results in quite the consequences. The closest other to it that I can think of is the film, Primer, though elements of it can be seen in various other time travel media, ranging from All You Zombies to El ministerio del tiempo. A detailed explanation is given for technical aspects of how the time travel would hypothetically work, though the specific process isn't ever explicitly shown. As happens with time travel stories, the narrative isn't told linearly, and there's some initial obfuscation of identities, though eventually everything is clearly explained to the reader.
In terms of its historical accuracy, it reads very well and is clearly researched, which is evidenced by the bibliography provided at the end. Sometimes (oftentimes?) with science fiction the origin of the book simply seems to be that the author has been deeply researching some area of interest and then decide they want to write about it. I've seen this in a wide variety of works and overall I think doing so enhances their writing with the distinct flavor of their research. That goes from "write what you know" to "write what you learned."
Once again I'd like to thank yitr for suggesting that I read Crowley sooner than later. It's only a matter of time before I'll have read almost all, if not all, of Crowley's fiction. All of his works that I've read so far have had the sort of imaginative novelty that I particularly appreciate. Each one has that special something where even if I didn't enjoy it I can still respect it for what it is. Even his most read work is only mildly known, so I recommend you read him.
dave_white's review against another edition
3.0
It's good.. but some ideas are a bit burred in obscurity. I mean, it had more detailed description of soup they serve in club than some key plot points.
walford's review
5.0
Absolutely have to reread this every five years or so. The most intricate and haunting time-travel story I've ever encountered, impossible to describe (or remember, for that matter).
Please be aware that you can also find it in Novelties and Souvenirs: Collected Short Fiction
Please be aware that you can also find it in Novelties and Souvenirs: Collected Short Fiction
stevenf's review
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
5.0
A Great Writer! One of the best in the Time Travel genre.