Reviews

Moscou Contra 007 by Ian Fleming

arianappstrg's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark sad tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.0

I sometimes cast the net a little too wide in my reading escapades so this is more of a note-to-self than an actual helpful review. I'd like to revisit my year in books in 2026 and remind myself why I read the things I read and what I thought of them at the time.

With that in mind, lowkey hope it's not weird I enjoyed one of JFK's all time faves, man had issues and created some too, but you know what, that's some good taste in spy novels and I did read it twice for the thrills. That is only if you can split yourself in two and separate the subject matter of women from the actual spy stuff. Also aware there's this whole semi-controversial debate about accurate and realistic espionage novels - looking at you 'Bond vs Smiley' reddit page, I have visited thee - but if it does come up in a pub quiz, oh what have you in common with JFK, I can say... From Russia, With Love. Does that matter to anyone? N... nah. I did just realise I probably made this political without meaning to, given the history. Oups, redirect; you have to go into it for the pizzazz, the high jinks, the stunts, the wow moments and the descriptions of lady killers as a 'wet trap of a mouth, that went on opening and shutting as if it was operated by wires... had the same pale, thick chicken's skin that scragged in little folds under the eyes and at the corners of the mouth and below the jaws, the same big peasant's ears... tight hard dimpled fists like knobkerries tightly clenched... on either side of the big bundle of bosom... this dreadful woman of SMEEEEEEERSH' and scene . Very easy to see why it was so smoothly adapted into film, the writing alone does lend itself to screen, never mind the action. Also, very easy to take it all a little too seriously and see the story as an accurate depiction of its time and contend with the casual misogyny and constant violence against women duped into serving their country by serving ass, for lack of a better word. See it like that, you have lost the plot, my friend. On one or two occasions, when I read the word 'rape' being casually thrown around to mean 'oh, just a rough tumble', 'oh, fierce love-making', 'oh, this is how you teach them'... I could go on... I felt extremely revolted and unsure if these were the uncultured, rough views of the characters or the clandestine and criminal views of Mister Eaton-educated Fleming. Read a review at some point that suggested to 'laugh at the sexism instead of fume about it' and it cannot be truer, if you want to take away anything remotely action-based or thrilling from this novel you might as well read the sexism, racism, homophobia and misogyny as a sort of comical satirical sketch. I see it as the fictional representation of an alternate spy universe where women, for Fleming reasons, ask to be spanked if they get fat, crickets. Gurl. I think in his mind, he was probably enacting some, erm, intimate and violent concepts under the guise of Bond, man of England, man of the people, panty snatcher, woo hoo, can do no wrong. What the hell, in short, I am acknowledging the flaws while also enjoying the overall gratuitous fictionalised universe of the... uncultured in the ways of women. It remains a decent three stars because as a modern female-identifying individual, I cannot turn a blind eye that easily. That's it. That's the note.

PS: If JFK loved Bond's character then that says a fair bit about the affairs. You nasty. I'll tell you who needs a spanking or to be kept naked and starving under a table, biatch. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

iggy63's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Not the most action-packed installment I've read so far, but still a pretty good story. As Bond mopes in London following the loss of his last girl to another man(Tiffany Case in Diamonds Are Forever), he is lured to Istanbul. SMERSH has hatched a plot to discredit and kill England's premier spy, and uses the beautiful Tatiana Romanova as bait. Almost nothing happens in the first half of the book, other than Fleming's trademark writing style packed with detail, deep character development and rich descriptions of various locales. Fleming takes great pains to make the entire story plausible, almost to a fault. The action happens on the Orient Express from Istanbul to Paris, with a bit of cliffhanger ending that you never get in the film versions.

After decades of watching the films I find a lot of enjoyment in reading the original stories, despite the sexism and racism that often emerge in Fleming's writing. I find the book version of Bond much more human and believable.

mlrio's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Review | From Russia with Love, Ian Fleming | 4.5 Stars I love Ian Fleming. I really do. He’s got a gift for storytelling, he has the English language wrapped around his little finger, and perhaps most importantly, the man has an impeccable sense of style.
 
That being said, From Russia with Love had a love to live up to. This book is undoubtedly a modern classic. It’s probably the most famous in the James Bond series (possibly because JFK once mentioned it was one of his favorite novels; looking back on it JFK’s love of 007 probably makes more sense than the public originally realized). I have to admit, when I cracked it open I was a little afraid of being disappointed by it.
Thank God, I was so many levels of wrong.
 
From Russia with Love is undoubtedly the best in the series so far. It takes the finesse of the four previous novels, kicks it up a notch and delivers one of the most smashing spy thrillers I’ve ever read.
 
Time for me to gush about how riotously spectacular this book is.
 
First off, the title is an absolute home run. No discussion.
 
After that, the first 100 pages take the reader deep inside the sinister planning cabinet of SMERSH, and it’s clear from Fleming’s knowledge and confidence as a writer that he’s got experience to support the kind of detail that from any other writer would feel speculative at best. Interestingly, Bond himself doesn’t even appear until about a third of the way through the book. As a reader, you feel his absence acutely – not because the story’s boring, but because you have a growing sense of dread as the trap being laid out for him begins to take shape.
 
From the very beginning of Bond’s part of the story, there’s a sense of inevitable doom, and as each page turns the SMERSH plot seems to slowly close around him, like a venus flytrap. He doesn’t stumble blindly into it, of course, but nor does he fully understand what he’s walking into. For those of us who already know and love Bond, those who are meeting him for the first time and especially, I would imagine, those who were reading it when it was first published without the comforting knowledge that there would be a sequel, ‘tension’ doesn’t even begin to cover it.
 
But that alone isn’t what makes this book wonderful. It’s also perhaps the most geographically rich book in the series (so far). Bond is no stranger to exotic locales, but his adventures in Istanbul are almost more akin to the hi-jinks of an Indiana Jones movie than the city-slicker, money-to-burn explorations of the first four books. From rat-infested tunnels below the city to a naked wrestling death-match in a nearby gypsy camp, From Russia with Love is a story stepped in rich cultural detail.
 
And then there’s the train. Oh, the train. I may be a little biased here, because I LOVE trains, but all the action on board the Orient Express is made much more exciting by the sheer forward momentum of the journey. I could go on about this for ages, but I won’t.
 

 
Once Bond is off the train and ostensibly out of danger, it’s still almost impossible to relax, and with good reason – it all seems a little too easy. SMERSH isn’t quite so easily duped, and to the very last page, Bond and the reader are both waiting for the other shoe to drop – which it finally does, with (possibly) fatal results. The ending is a cliffhanger of the highest degree. The only reason I’m not already reading Dr. No is because I left it on the mainland and won’t be back there for another two weeks.
 
Really, I could stop here, but I think it would be remiss to write a Bond review without mentioning the girl. Tatiana Romanova is not, at first, too terribly different from the other women who have come and gone in James Bond’s life (Fleming clearly had a penchant for women with blue eyes). But unlike the other girls, the reader gets a much more intimate idea of what’s going on her head. She appears before Bond does, and you can’t help but wonder when she’s going to realize that she’s being lured into a trap as much as Bond is. Unfortunately, she doesn’t get to see much action. This is really a shame, because Fleming goes out of his way to explain how intelligent she is. I for one would have liked to have seen her take a more active role in the story, considering she’s unconscious or absent for the most crucial scenes in the book (this is honestly all that’s keeping me from giving this one a five-star rating). I liked her, though, and in the end the story really isn’t about her – she’s just another one of SMERSH’s pawns.
 
So. From Russia with Love is unquestionably worth a read, whether you pick it up as part of the series or if it’s the only Bond book you ever crack open. There’s a little something for everyone – and even if sweeping international espionage  isn’t your style, prepare to be sucked in by the inimitable style of Fleming’s prose. Here’s one of my favorite passages, just to whet your appetite:
 

It should have been the Arabian Nights, but to Bond, seeing it first above the tops of trams and above the great scars of modern advertising along the river frontage, it seemed a once beautiful theatre-set that modern Turkey had thrown aside in favour of the steel and concrete flat-iron of the Istanbul-Hilton Hotel, blankly glittering behind him on the heights of Pera.
 
–From Russia with Love, Ian Fleming

 
4.5 stars.

lee_foust's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This one was so well set up! I enjoyed the long lead in (was it 6 or 8 chapters before we even saw Bond?), the perverse and creepy soviet characters, verging on camp the whole way in that sick, inimitable Fleming way. Appreciated that this one was more linear than the previous Bond novels (been reading them in order). Istanbul scenes great, Orient Express cool--but then the solution? C'mon! A deus ex machina so old Woody Allen used to joke about it in his stand-up act in the 1950s. So the novel makes the Soviets look sick, but totally ingenious and Bond rather as an idiot who just lucks out in the end--and then is outsmarted a second time and killed in the postscript scene. Surely Fleming will explain that one away in the opening scene of the next opus like the old serial cliffhangers of the 1930s and '40s--the same serials that are easily the lowest form of art produced in the Western World (yes, I find pornography far more advanced) and the inspiration for all that Star Wars and Raiders of the Penultimate Covenant shit. Sigh. Almost.

murdrean's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense medium-paced

4.25

catherine_t's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.75

James Bond has interfered with SMERSH's plans one time too many. Now they're out for revenge. Baiting the hook with a beautiful young woman and a Russian encryption machine, SMERSH lures Bond to Istanbul. Will 007 manage to escape their clutches?

Ian Fleming novels are a guilty pleasure of mine. His Bond is a cruel, hard man, not the charmer of the films. But Bond lives in the hard, cruel world of postwar Europe and the long slide into the Cold War. I enjoy the books as historical fiction, though they were current at the time they were published. I wouldn't want to meet this Bond in a dark alley, unless he was firmly on my side of the fight.

mywonderfulsea's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes

3.75

natethek's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

My first attempt at reading Fleming was a false start for whatever reason, and I've never been especially enamored of the Bond character. This novel, however, is a masterpiece of Cold War intrigue.

breakiemimosa's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Let's make one thing clear: this is pulp fiction, full of sex, violence, misogyny and racist remarks. It's also, by far, the best James Bond novel I've read so far. The plot is more subtle and more believable than the previous four novels. It also plays on Bond's weaknesses and hubris.

geowhaley's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

For my first, and probably only, foray into James Bond this was definitely a good one. Compared to other spy novels I've read like The Talented Mr. Ripley or The Thin Man, I enjoyed this one the most! I'm not sure if it is because of the history of the novel, or because of the character James Bond.

So it will come as no surprise, that this is my local library's books into movies book group February read. What is surprising is that I suggested it. I did so because for some random reason, I have always been obsessed with the title—it's one of those iconic titles that everyone knows and for some reason it's always stuck with me even though I've never seen the movie or read the book. The second reason is that it's February and well, Valentine's Day. And finally Caroline made another connection: oh Russia, like Sochi, and the Olympics. So yet another great reason.

Continue reading on my book blog at geoffwhaley.com.