Reviews

Washington: The Indispensable Man by James Thomas Flexner

jwmortensen's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I have always felt like I admired Washington and now I know why. Flexner does an excellent job of honestly portraying an imperfect man who is nonetheless one of the greatest Americans of all time. Humble and principled, Washington diligently sought to always do what was best for his fellow men and country.

mburnamfink's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Flexner wrote a massive four volume biography of Washington, which he then condensed into this more approachable 400 page book. As the subtitle, The Indispensible Man indicates, Flexner places Washington in his keystone role in the history of America. Washington rose from the lower-ranks of the Virginia planter aristocracy through land speculation, and a minor military career in the French and Indian Wars. Snubbed by British officers, he focused on American independence in economic matters, and then when the Revolution occurred, became the leader of the Continental Army, and the first President, setting the traditions for the American republic.

Again and again, Washington's virtues are persistence and equanimity. At many points where others would have given up in despair, or resorted to personal attacks, Washington held firm to his course. He held the army together through desperate retreats and the bitter winter at Valley Forge. As President, he managed conflict between Hamilton's Federalists and Jefferson's Democratic-Republicans. Washington did not always choose wisely, and particularly in his old age, and following the break with Thomas Jefferson, he became more partisan, more paranoid, less able to unify the country and plot a wise course. In large part, he did what few others could, and well-earned his place in history.

Flexner deserves credit for earnestly engaging with the slavery issue at the end of the book, as I was waiting for it to come up. Washington was born into a slave society, but in Flexner's account, slowly turned against it. He wanted to end the slave system at Mount Vernor, but was constrained by the lack of alternatives. He freed what slaves he could, but many were property of Martha Washington (nee Custis), and would pass to the Custises. And while this is a good look at the man and the period, it lacks the vividness of a truly great biography.

bayleekc's review against another edition

Go to review page

slow-paced

2.0

cspiwak's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I learned a lot. Washington is far more human to me now, but I like him even better