Reviews

India in Slow Motion by Mark Tully

pankajmehra's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Mark and his wife Gillian are "old India hands" as the Brit expression from the Raj goes. They understand the nuances of life in India and have brought forth the many individuals and incidents covered in this "dated" book very well. I reread this book after several years. Some things and people never change. Mark and Gillian have honestly recorded on all that they then saw and experienced. Nothing has changed, it would appear!

ashwinn's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Mark Tully has been reporting for BBC in India for more than 20 years. He's been in the thick of everything that has shaped our nation — the Emergency, Indira's and Rajiv's assassinations, the droughts, the floods, the IT wave and the liberalization. Mark Tully and Gillian Wright travelled extensively around India talking to people of all kinds about India's past and present problems for their book India In Slow Motion.

The book is broken into sections, each dealing with a problem facing our country. Some of the subjects of the book are Kashmir, water, farmer suicides, child labour and religion. The travels to far-off places, the interviews with rustic people are delightful and eye opening. In every single aspect, the government and bureaucracy turn out to be impediments. Also, it seems like the state governments have little autonomy, having to depend on the Center for everything. This stands out clearly in the progressive states for whom the Center has just become a roadblock. And even in this bleak landscape, there are people with the spirit to make change. The takeaway for me from the book was the extensive historical origins of each problem that the authors detail. Tully does satirical takes on everything and everyone. For Indians, it might be a bit depressing to go through the book in a single read. I read it over several nights, this was easy since it is broken into independent sections. This is a good thoughtful read.

sheelal's review

Go to review page

5.0

i absolutely loved that he dissected smaller state or thematic issues to reflect larger realities about contemporary india. appreciated the narration and contextualization. must must read for anyone with a base understanding of indian politics.